关于递增型腹膜透析优劣性的回顾性分析

    Retrospective analysis of advantages and disadvantages of incremental peritoneal dialysis

    • 摘要: 目的 探讨递增型腹膜透析(incremental peritoneal dialysis,incr-PD)较标准型腹膜透析(standard peritoneal dialysis,st-PD)在透析充分性、腹膜炎发生、残余肾功能(residual kinedy function,RKF)影响等方面的优劣性,为incr-PD的临床应用提供有力依据。方法 回顾性研究上海交通大学附属第一人民医院南院肾内科2012年1月1日至2018年12月31日腹膜透析(peritoneal dialysis,PD)随访病例,根据纳入及排除标准,进行病例筛选,以透析方案分为递增组与标准组。分析两组基线特征、透析后3个月、6个月、1年、2年、3年相关指标,同时对比两组腹膜炎发生率、初次发生腹膜炎时间、平均尿量变化、残余肾丢失时间、初次外周水肿时间、住院率、病死率、PD技术生存时间、第1年透析费用等方面。结果 共纳入病例115例,递增组78例,标准组37例,两组间基线特征除初始尿量存在差异(1030.00 比906.50 mL,P=0.014),余指标均差异无统计学意义(P均≥0.05)。透析后3个月,递增组总Kt/V(1.85比1.51,P<0.001)和总肌酐清除(77.25比61.57 L/周,P=0.006)高于标准组。透析后1年,递增组总肌酐清除(54.23比37.19 L/周,P=0.010)高于标准组。余指标在随访期间均差异无统计学意义(P值均≥0.05)。至随访结束,递增组残余肾丢失时间(24.00比15.00/月,P=0.017)、平均尿量减少(39.04比59.71 mL/月,P=0.022)、估算肾小球滤过率降低2.95 比4.54 mL·min-1·(1.73m2)-1,P=0.003、初次发生腹膜炎时间(22.00比14.00/月,P=0.035)、住院率(0.09比0.15次/人月,P<0.001)及第1年透析费用(3.20比4.27万元)均优于标准组。在初次发生外周水肿时间(13.50 比13.00/月,P=0.673)、PD技术生存时间(28.50比25.00/月,P=0.515)、腹膜透析治疗时间(time on therapy in PD,TOT)(42.96比43.62/月,P=0.335)、退队率(drop out rate,DOR)(第一年14.10% 比16.21%,第二年39.74% 比 48.65%,第三年56.41% 比62.16%,P=0.937)、病死率(7.69%比13.51%,P=0.487)等方面两组间差异无统计学意义,同时发现年龄、性别、高血压、糖尿病并不影响PD技术生存时间,腹膜炎发生率与残余肾丢失时间是其重要危险因素。结论 Incr-PD在保留有RKF的终末期肾病患者中运用是完全可行的。Incr-PD在不影响PD技术生存时间、TOT、DOR、病死率、透析充分性同时,有利于减缓RKF下降,延长初次发生腹膜炎时间,降低住院率及医疗费用。

       

      Abstract: Objective To explore the advantages and disadvantages of incremental peritoneal dialysis(incr-PD) versus standard peritoneal dialysis(st-PD) in dialysis adequacy,peritonitis and residual kidney function(RKF) and provide further rationales for clinical application of incr-PD.Methods For this single-center retrospective cohort study,PD patients admitted from January 1,2012 to December 31,2018 were collected.According to the inclusion and exclusion criteria,they were assigned into two groups of incremental(n=78) and standard(n=37) dialysis scheme.Baseline profiles,related parameters of 3/6/12/24/36 months post-dialysis were compared between two groups.At the same time,peritoneal infection frequency,peritonitis-free survival time,average change of urine volume,urine-free survival time,initial peripheral edema time,hospitalization rate,mortality rate,PD survival time and dialysis cost in the first year were compared between two groups.Results Baseline profiles between two groups were not significantly different (all P≥0.05).Initial urine volume was significantly different(1030.00 vs 906.50 mL,P= 0.014).After 3-month PD,total Kt/V(1.85 vs 1.51,P<0.001) and total creatinine clearance rate(77.25 vs 61.57 L/week,P=0.006) were higher in incremental group than those in standard group.After 6-month PD,total creatinine clearance was higher in incremental group than those in standard group(54.23 vs 37.19 L/week,P= 0.010).No significant difference existed in the above parameters during follow-ups (all P≥ 0.05).At the end of follow-ups,incremental group had better urine-free survival time(24.00 vs 15.00/month,P=0.017) ,lower urine volume(39.04 vs 59.71 mL/month,P=0.022) ,lower eGFR2.95 vs 4.54 mL·min-1·(1.73m2)-1 ,P=0.003 ,peritonitis-free survival time(22.00 vs 14.00/month,P=0.035) ,hospitalization rate(0.09 vs 0.15 times/patient-months,P<0.001) and dialysis cost in the first year (32 000 vs 42 700 yuan) than standard group.No significant inter-group differences existed in initial peripheral edema time(13.50 vs 13.00/month,P=0.673),PD survival time(28.50 vs 25.00/month,P=0.515),TOT(42.96 vs 43.62/month,P=0.335) ,DOR(first year 14.10% vs 16.21%,second year 39.74% vs 48.65%,third year 56.41% vs 62.16%,P=0.937)or mortality rate(7.69% vs 13.51%,P=0.487).Meanwhile,age,gender,hypertension and diabetes mellitus did not affect PD survival time.However,peritoneal infection frequency and urine-free survival time were important risk factors.Conclusion Incr-PD is completely feasible in ESRD patients with residual renal function.Incr-PD does not affect PD survival time,time on therapy,dropout rate,mortality or dialysis adequacy.At the same time,it may arrest the deterioration of kidney function,prolong peritonitis-free survival time,lower hospitalization rate and reduce medical expenses.

       

    /

    返回文章
    返回